Financial services complaint management: How to handle compliance for customer or client complaints
- Regulations require that financial institutions and other financial services businesses maintain robust complaint management systems and processes to handle customer complaints.
- Compliance in this area may be overseen by both federal and state regulators and includes making sure you have an effective process for intaking, investigating, documenting, remediating and reporting on customer complaints.
- Viewing complaints as a risk management issue and working with a third-party risk and compliance advisor can help you reduce your risk of regulatory problems and customer frustrations in this area.
Complaint management is a crucial aspect of risk management and regulatory compliance in the financial services sector. Financial institutions, insurance companies and investment firms are all subject to federal and state regulations and standards that require them to handle complaints fairly, effectively and transparently.
How can your financial services firm strengthen its compliance in this area? Keep reading to learn key regulatory expectations, plus recommendations to better handle customer, member or client complaints.
What are the key regulatory requirements for complaint management in financial services?
Financial institutions and other financial services businesses are required to meet certain regulatory requirements around complaint management. These include establishing a clear process to handle consumer complaints, training staff, promptly acknowledging complaints, conducting a fair and thorough investigation and offering appropriate remedies.
Key complaint management requirements include:
- A clear process: Financial institutions and services firms must establish and maintain a clear and accessible complaint policy and procedure that informs customers of their rights and obligations, the steps and timeframes for resolving complaints and the available channels and options for escalating complaints.
- Team training: Also essential is providing adequate training and resources to staff who are responsible for receiving, investigating and resolving complaints, as well as ensuring that they act in a professional, courteous and impartial manner.
- Prompt response: You must acknowledge and register complaints promptly and provide customers with regular updates and communication throughout the complaint process.
- Thorough and fair investigation: Conduct a thorough and fair investigation of complaints and provide customers with a clear and reasoned explanation of the outcome and your rationale behind it.
- Appropriate remedies: Offer appropriate and proportionate remedies or redress to customers who have suffered harm or loss due to your financial institution or business’s actions or inactions and implement them without undue delay.
- Accurate records: Keeping records and data of complaints and their resolutions.
- Monitor the process: Monitor and review your complaint management process and performance. Identify and address any systemic issues, trends or areas for improvement.
Which federal agencies are involved in complaint management compliance for the financial services sector?
Depending on the jurisdiction and the type of financial service, different regulators and agencies may oversee your compliance with statutory complaint management requirements. At the federal level, key regulators include:
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) is responsible for enforcing compliance with federal consumer protection laws and supervising the complaint handling of financial institutions, mortgage lenders, debt collectors and other financial service providers.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) handles consumer complaints against insurance companies.
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FIRA) investigates consumer complaints against investment firms.
Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) regulates certain national financial institutions and federal savings associations and can get involved in customer disputes involving institutions under its purview.
Complaint management is a risk management issue
Effective complaint management is essentially a regulatory risk issue. If you don’t have an effective process in place that complies with regulatory requirements, you can face penalties, which may include fines.
This means that thinking about complaints from a risk management perspective can help your institution or business avoid unnecessary headaches. To mitigate your risks here, you’ll benefit from working with an advisor who has experience in regulatory risk and compliance specifically for the financial services sector.
What are the core components of an effective complaint management system?
An effective complaint management system includes key elements. These can be broken into three general stages: Intake, investigation and management oversight.
Complaint intake, classification and documentation
Your complaint management system needs an intake process for new complaints. This should include a way of categorizing complaints based on the nature of the problem. You should also document all aspects of the complaint and the investigation.
Investigation, escalation and remedies workflows
After you intake a new complaint, your team needs to conduct a thorough investigation. This may involve escalating the complaint to a manager if needed. You also need a clear process for remedying a complaint if your investigation finds that it has merit.
Management reporting and trend analysis
Finally, you should be conducting an ongoing review of your complaints. You want to watch for trends or patterns that may indicate a broader problem for your team to deal with.
Practices that will help improve your complaint management system
Financial institutions and other financial services businesses can reduce their risk of regulatory issues or customer frustration by implementing additional practices to strengthen their complaint management processes. These can include:
- Promoting a positive, proactive complaint culture that encourages customers to voice their concerns and feedback and values complaints as an opportunity for learning and improvement.
- Providing customers with multiple convenient complaint channels, such as phone, email, online forms, social media or in-person options.
- Empowering front-line staff to resolve complaints at the first point of contact, whenever possible and providing them with the authority and discretion to offer remedies or redress.
- Seeking customer feedback on the complaint process and outcome and using it to measure and improve the quality and effectiveness of the complaint management.
- Benchmarking and comparing your complaint management performance and practices with other financial institutions and adopting widespread practices and innovations in the industry.
- Engaging with external stakeholders, such as consumer advocates, ombudsmen or mediators to seek their input and advice on your complaint management process and policies and to resolve complex or escalated complaints.
Common complaint management FAQs in financial services
Here are common FAQs you may find useful:
How do financial institutions use complaints data during regulatory examinations?
Regulators will review your complaints data, as well as assess your processes to help ensure you are in compliance with appropriate regulations.
What role does the CFPB play in financial services complaint management?
CFPB maintains a key regulatory oversight role over financial services firms. Consumers can also make a complaint directly with the CFPB, which may then investigate that complaint on the consumer’s behalf.
What is an OCC complaint and why does it matter for financial institutions?
The OCC provides regulatory oversight for certain national financial institutions and federal savings associations. Account holders at those institutions can also make a complaint directly with the OCC.
What are the common complaint management gaps regulators identify?
Regulators may find fault with any aspect of how you handle complaints, including areas like intake process, communication with individuals who file complaints, promptness, ease of filing, remedies or documentation and reporting.
How should complaint management be reported on to senior management and your board?
Your senior management and board should be aware of your high-level complaints trends, as well as any regulatory issues.
How Wipfli can help
Wipfli advises financial institutions and other financial services businesses on regulatory compliance and risk management. Let’s talk about how we can strengthen your processes — including complaint management — to satisfy regulators and reduce your risks. Start a conversation.
Let’s talk stronger regulatory compliance